|
Post by pandapirate on Sept 16, 2015 6:40:34 GMT -8
The mutineers think it's Cid.
Mccoy would be my personal second guess.
|
|
|
Post by landlubber on Sept 16, 2015 9:09:10 GMT -8
We have a couple clues to go on:
1) Kraken is not Flynn (Kraken killed while Flynn was in jail at the beginning when the game rules prevented a jailed Kraken from killing) 2) Kraken is not a mutineer (That eliminates pandapirate and Rackham from the suspect list) 3) Kraken drew a self-portrait of itself and the drawing was partially revealed during Evan's video. However, the resolution was not that great. We can either try to find someone who has a similar drawing style or target those who did not enter the drawing challenge.
|
|
cid
Super Person
Posts: 130
|
Post by cid on Sept 16, 2015 9:14:23 GMT -8
The mutineers think it's Cid. Mccoy would be my personal second guess. I know the mutineers are butt hurt after being on the brink of destruction and being exposed by me time after time. But since we're a team now, maybe they should start thinking hunting the kraken instead of revenge. If not, one of you mutineers need to start gathering up dead crows to eat. I'm not the kraken, but if mutineers want to waste their vote, I can't tell them what to do.
|
|
|
Post by pandapirate on Sept 16, 2015 9:42:42 GMT -8
lolz, my butt doesn't hurt. You were the team that needed help first. This holding hand thing was the pirate's doing. I still think it's you Cid
|
|
cid
Super Person
Posts: 130
|
Post by cid on Sept 16, 2015 9:59:55 GMT -8
If you think it is me, at least provide some reasons why you suspect me of being Kraken. If you have any evidence, that would help convince people (that aren't mutineers) to see why you think I am the Kraken. If you don't have any reasons or evidence, the only conclusion I can think of why you want to vote me off is revenge.
|
|
|
Post by williammccoy on Sept 16, 2015 10:00:53 GMT -8
I'm not the Kraken or I would have eaten Jack Tappers that week and just said the Kraken was trying to frame me. I'd love to hear your reasoning for why I'm the kraken though.
|
|
|
Post by Fluffy Rob on Sept 16, 2015 11:06:52 GMT -8
I'm sure one of you has a color coded chart showing who was jailed when, when the kraken ate and who they ate. The kraken sized hole in the jail appeared in week 5 I think. So anyone in jail before week 5 and also during a week that the Kraken feasted, is innocent.
|
|
|
Post by The Dread Pirate Roberts on Sept 16, 2015 12:00:16 GMT -8
We have a couple clues to go on: 1) Kraken is not Flynn (Kraken killed while Flynn was in jail at the beginning when the game rules prevented a jailed Kraken from killing) 2) Kraken is not a mutineer (That eliminates pandapirate and Rackham from the suspect list) 3) Kraken drew a self-portrait of itself and the drawing was partially revealed during Evan's video. However, the resolution was not that great. We can either try to find someone who has a similar drawing style or target those who did not enter the drawing challenge. Landlubber has his shit in order. Flynn is the only person who was in jail when there wasn't a Kraken-hole in the jail. The next week DPR won the challenge and he jailed no one. The two weeks after that, the Kraken did not feast (which implicated vitaminc). The mutineers are also exempt. Here is a list of the living: • cid - suspect• DPR - highly suspect• landlubber • sidmeier • The Dread Pirate Roberts • thebay • williammccoy • Dread Pirate Rackham (mutineer) • pandapirate (mutineer) • piratebooty (mutineer) • Richard "Swabbie" Flynn (jailed week 1 while Kraken feasted) Here's a screenshot of the Kraken's challenge submission: and enhanced: This appears to be pencil on plain, white paper. It looks quite similar to cid's submission— which he is currently using as his profile picture. I think that's pretty damn suspicious (and quite arrogant, if he is the Kraken). Cid also submitted his drawing long before anyone else, possibly because he did it directly after submitting the Kraken's drawing to the Captain. Landlubber's submission was the only other pencil drawing, and it was on lined paper and very primitive. Assuming that the Kraken actually submitted a drawing publicly, cid's drawing is the only one that is even remotely close. However, the primary target at this time has to be DPR. We can't forget what happened in week 2. He won a challenge randomly (ship's name vote), which means that he might not have expect to win, but still wanted to participate so he could blend in. After winning, he chose to not jail anyone. That could have been due to inactivity on his part, but if he had jailed himself (as one would expect), he wouldn't have been able to feast, which would have drawn suspicion. The next two weeks after that, the Kraken did not eat, which implicated vitaminc, whom the mutineers killed. We needed the Kraken to kill mutineers, so we didn't go after him, but now, we have to at least eliminate the possibility that it is DPR, because there's just too much evidence against him. After that, cid appears to be the only person with any evidence against him, so he should be next. In summary, DPR should be our target. If that fails, it the next target should be cid.
|
|
|
Post by Fluffy Rob on Sept 16, 2015 12:47:21 GMT -8
do we know when the Kraken submitted his drawing? Couldn't it have been after people submitted theirs online?
|
|
|
Post by The Dread Pirate Roberts on Sept 16, 2015 13:13:36 GMT -8
do we know when the Kraken submitted his drawing? Couldn't it have been after people submitted theirs online? I'm assuming that the Captain discussed this with the Kraken before making it a challenge, which would have given the Kraken a head start. It would have been quite awkward if the Kraken ended up not participating in the challenge for some reason. Still, it's possible that the Kraken submitted his drawing later. It's not a piece of evidence that would stand on its own, but seems to be part of a pattern that implicates cid.
|
|
|
Post by Fluffy Rob on Sept 16, 2015 13:52:01 GMT -8
I don't trust nones of yous.
|
|
Jack Tappers
Super Person
Ready to plunder yer booty
Posts: 208
|
Post by Jack Tappers on Sept 16, 2015 15:28:07 GMT -8
Kraken candidate #1 is cid
-Has very strong opinions about what the Kraken "really" looks like -Uses his depiction, which he is adamant is the only correct one, as his avatar -Said "If I'm going down, I'm taking one of you with me," which implies he would use his Kraken ability against the people who tried to kill him -might be Stabby, who expressed concern in the "Next Time" thread about the Kraken's ability to participate once dead -Stabby's reprehensible life choices would gravitate chance to make him the kraken -might be Amer, because of how much he blarfs the conversation, and if so is currently making the same mistake he did on the mildville express: panicking
|
|
Jack Tappers
Super Person
Ready to plunder yer booty
Posts: 208
|
Post by Jack Tappers on Sept 16, 2015 15:32:45 GMT -8
do we know when the Kraken submitted his drawing? Couldn't it have been after people submitted theirs online? I'm assuming that the Captain discussed this with the Kraken before making it a challenge, which would have given the Kraken a head start. This is correct, he collected the kraken's portrait before putting up the challenge
|
|
|
Post by Fluffy Rob on Sept 16, 2015 15:53:28 GMT -8
Is the drawing the only thing you got on cid?
|
|
|
Post by Fluffy Rob on Sept 16, 2015 15:56:09 GMT -8
I presume the known non krakens will be jailed?
|
|
|
Post by Evan on Sept 16, 2015 16:08:02 GMT -8
I'm assuming that the Captain discussed this with the Kraken before making it a challenge, which would have given the Kraken a head start. This is correct, he collected the kraken's portrait before putting up the challenge Not confirming this. Also, "color coded chart," brings back memories. Was that season 1?
|
|
Jack Tappers
Super Person
Ready to plunder yer booty
Posts: 208
|
Post by Jack Tappers on Sept 16, 2015 16:08:07 GMT -8
Is the drawing the only thing you got on cid? The main thing against him to me is his use of language, but there is corroborative reasoning as follows: I think that the kraken would try to imitate a different enough art style from the original, while still taking advantage of his knowledge of the original's spatial arrangement. Cid's is primary for that. I fully expect cid to continue asking for evidence and claiming we have none. Classic flailing. Even if we had nothing to go on, you don't get to put the kraken as your avatar and not get killed. If you're innocent, you're a bad person for sabotaging your own team so fuck your vote. If you're not, we dodge the "haha you should've known because I told you it was me" bullet. Same shit as when neutrino claimed to be a merperson in his sig.
|
|
Amer
Super Person
My super power is tremendous wealth.
Posts: 372
|
Post by Amer on Sept 16, 2015 16:18:47 GMT -8
Also, "color coded chart," brings back memories. Was that season 1? Uh, bro, it's every season.
|
|
Jack Tappers
Super Person
Ready to plunder yer booty
Posts: 208
|
Post by Jack Tappers on Sept 16, 2015 17:01:28 GMT -8
Kraken candidate #1 is cid -Has very strong opinions about what the Kraken "really" looks like I'm retarded, that was The Dread Pirate Roberts. Upon further inspection, his submission was indeed the same shape as the kraken's, while avoiding the betrayal of his hand by moving to a different medium.
|
|
cid
Super Person
Posts: 130
|
Post by cid on Sept 16, 2015 17:06:14 GMT -8
I thank Annie for at least trying to find some truth, as The Dread Pirate Roberts has decided to hop on the "kill" cid bandwagon.
The value in what Jerk Slappers says has no value whatsoever, as his statements of me having strong opinions what the Kraken looks like is not true and trying to "assert" that the Captain has already collected Kraken's self portrait before putting up the challenge without proof. Although it is possible and likely that he did, the Captain has not confirmed it, which means you can as best assume it, not state it as a fact Alex.
If I wasn't in the death's door, I actually like The Dread Pirate Roberts' analysis and reasoning, although there is not much to go on.
But with the his reasons why he thinks I'm the Kraken, I can say those reasons are why I am NOT the Kraken.
There are three major reasons that I got from TDPR analysis: - My current profile picture is of the Kraken - I was the first one who submitted and did so way before anyone else - My picture is black and white and looks closest to the Kraken's submission.
All of these points are true, but there is one point that you all have forgotten, he made us think VitaminC was the kraken. The hint, the only behavior we can know from the Kraken is that he or she was wlling to give up 2 weeks of eating to frame someone. The mutineers obviously though VitaminC was the Kraken, but it turned out VitaminC was a pirate. This very fact shows that the Kraken will frame someone to keep themselves hiding. This fact seems to suggest that the reason why the Kraken's submission looks so much similar to mine is because he tried to imitate mine.
This fact also points out that the fact I posted the drawing of my Kraken so early means that there was ample of time for the Kraken to draw a picture similar to mine and frame me. The 2nd and 3rd points suggest that there was enough time for me to be framed, and that the fact they look similar is that they are trying to frame me.
Also the last reason, where my current profile picture is of my kraken drawing does not match the behavior of the Kraken. So far, the Kraken has been crafty and alluded us. If I was the Kraken, does it make any sense to point a red big target on my back? After trying to hide the fact that I was Kraken for so long? I don't match the profile of the Kraken.
|
|