Immunity Challenge Week 1 : RESULTS posted!

[alex]

You're posting this on the day of my return party. That's for harshing my Friday.

[Super Sarah]

Question about the judgment and definitions: if the item in the picture is edible, even if it's gross to eat, would I still answer "this is food"? And, what if the picture is of an inedible part of something that is food?

[Evan]

Jul 15, 2011 17:43:40 GMT -8 Super Sarah said:

Question about the judgment and definitions: if the item in the picture is edible, even if it's gross to eat, would I still answer "this is food"? And, what if the picture is of an inedible part of something that is food?

Inedible pictures of stuff is food. Like if I show a bunch of turkey feathers that are attached to a turkey, yeah that's food. Good question.

People are not food.

Stuff that is edible, but not food doesn't count, it will make you sick.

[Son Anheuser]

If I am Asian and have a much more expansive view of what is considered food, does cultural perspective play a part in this?

[Evan]

Jul 15, 2011 18:23:07 GMT -8 Son Anheuser said:

If I am Asian and have a much more expansive view of what is considered food, does cultural perspective play a part in this?

No. I don't know.

[Super Sarah]

Ok, so if you show a shell and I can eat the clam that is food. But what about a lizard or a cat? still edible though not traditional.

[Evan]

Jul 15, 2011 18:45:27 GMT -8 Super Sarah said:

Ok, so if you show a shell and I can eat the clam that is food. But what about a lizard or a cat? still edible though not traditional.

Yes, that's exactly it. Also I think it would be dumb of me to show an animal like a giraffe and then debate whether or not it is edible.

[Son Anheuser]

Hmmm I think I just played this game wrong. Reading instructions is not my strong suit.

[dj]

They all look like Anthony Wiener's underwear.

[Super Sarah]

Well since it's too late to submit I may as well ask if anyone got them all right? I got all excited because I thought the winner would be announced today but then I re-read the rules.

Hey Evan are you going to tell us what the pictures are of? I'm dying to know...

[Mike Lenin]

Jul 15, 2011 18:53:48 GMT -8 Evan said:

Jul 15, 2011 18:45:27 GMT -8 Super Sarah said:

Ok, so if you show a shell and I can eat the clam that is food. But what about a lizard or a cat? still edible though not traditional.

Giraffes are technically kosher!

www.kashrut.com/articles/giraffe/

Yes, that's exactly it. Also I think it would be dumb of me to show an animal like a giraffe and then debate whether or not it is edible.