I was specifically interested in whether Mike "slipped up" and "leaked" that the witches voted out one of their own in week one. That's what Kyle told us. I've never seen anyone else confirm that Mike said that to them.
Sorry for the confusion, but I am confirming that I received the exact same PM.
I also got the PM from Mike after he was killed....I think all humans did.
So I just went through all of Mike's and Sarah's old posts because I like to procrastinate at work but mainly because I wanted to see if known witches had any patterns. This is what I found
1. Trying not to make enemies. I think Mike normally doesn't care about stepping on toes but he seemed to compliment others a lot. Sarah too seemed to back off of conversations that became heated.
2. Posting random non game related stuff. This might not be a good indicator at all since most probably do this out of boredom or whatever but perhaps they were doing it for distraction.
3. Asking a lot of questions relating to the rules and challenges. This is actually only Sarah and is probably because she is a good player and was looking for loopholes to exploit.
4. Not ganging up. Neither of them ever really ganged up on anyone no doubt because they didn't want to give themselves away. Instead they were very subtle about their allegations.
Based on these findings, I will now go through every other players history and report my findings.
If anyone else has any evidence please bring it forward, we still have about 6 hours to break up this coven.
Initial findings based on speed reading ~1000 posts:
Amer - very human, he plays the game like I did in Mildville 1 DJ - barely human, just too random to fit the witch profile Erok - slightly human, I didn't read him trying to subtly shift any votes Chris - kinda witchey, anti-Amer in a subtle way, off topic posts Stinky Pete - very witchey, tries to cause a lot of confusion like Chris admitted to doing back when he was the villain, Pete also tried to get others to vote for Tulley and Me Annie - Slightly witchey, definitely very subtle Alex - just a little witchey, tries to make friends with others
The others, Steve & Kyle, didn't have enough posts of substance to go on either way
Keep in mind this is just one thing to consider into evidence. We also need to keep in mind voting records and outside game conversations.
when have i ever given flimsy evidence, son? And i'm not referring to your name, I'm referring to the derogatory term that is calling someone a child.
voting history and lack of any attempt to find a witch. you've been sitting back, seems like you're trying not to draw attention
Dude, my voting history is pretty clean. Only during week 1, when I couldn't even find mildville on the internet was my vote a bogey. Voting stinky pete was a wild guess.
My next two weeks of voting Amer were only an act of rebellion to his long winded circular diatribes that kept pointing out that I'm "weird" and simultaneously leading misguided mobs to vote Tulley, who swore and put money down that he was a human. I don't consider them bogeys, simply because he led us in the wrong direction and I thought it was a ploy.
Then, I voted with the herd last week, before everyone changed their minds from Chris to Dan. Last week I had ten minutes of internet time and I wasted away in mildville.
I check the boards alot mostly because I'm inbetween jobs right now and I really don't post unless I can add something useful, which is never. Also the boards seem to get alot of action on Wednesdays.
That said, I'm torn between Chris (I had no part in and voted against his "Let's kill Amer" campaign) and Stinky Pete, who may have not been a random guess and instead a premonition of stinky witch blood from the beginning.
Wow, Amer. These term paper posts really do make you feel warm inside. Exhale.