Post by Son Anheuser on Aug 19, 2011 5:29:08 GMT -8
Well according to something called math if witches vote out one more human the game is a lock for them.
So far Amer and Annie have avoided any real suspicion as witches. mainly because they voted one out the first week. But over the last couple weeks, if my memory is correct, part of the plan was to let a confirmed human decide who to vote for.
Tulley said Brad was his choice but then the votes went to Dan, vampire, but also, a non-witch.
This week I was asked to put forth a couple names. Erik and DJ were my choices. But then that was ignored in favour of Chris, again, non-witch.
Annie and Amer are both good players and it would not surprise me if they sacrificed Mike in week one to win the confidence of the humans. The last two weeks votes make me wonder.
Post by Son Anheuser on Aug 19, 2011 8:34:57 GMT -8
True, but you did end with this:
"If I my hypothesis is at all correct, I don't really see how Dan could be a witch but not Erok & vice versa. Since I like the idea of voting for a pilgrim, that leaves Brad, Kyle, & Steve. Of those 3, Brad has been super suspicious in his lack of participation, so I would go with him."
I was convinced by Annie and Brad that Chris was a better candidate than DJ. However, it didn't take much convincing. Chris was already near the top of my list. I already gave my reasons why I didn't think Erock was a good candidate.
At this point, you just pull a name out of a hat and you're almost as likely to get a witch as a human.
It doesn't matter, though. The game is over. The witches might not have a mathematical majority, but there's no fucking way you're getting ALL of the remaining humans to vote for the same player. Just look at the last vote.
Fine. Let Tulley and Son do it -- if they can. I don't need to hear the reason; Or the discussion. In fact, I'd prefer to not hear it. Come up with one person that we should vote for. Use Chris as a tiebreaker if you have to. As far as I'm concerned, game's already over anyway, so I'll vote for anyone.
Brad, DJ and Erock we proposed last two weeks. I think this week's vote should be one of them to see how it turns out.
See, this is what I meant when I said you two needed to quietly discuss this and come back with one name. Throwing out suggestions is half the reason why we can't get everyone to vote for the same person.