Post by Amer on Jul 21, 2011 3:16:28 GMT -8
Turns out Mike was a witch after all. Now, let's get all the incriminating evidence in one place and see what it tells us.
First, I mentioned the three least active natives:
alex....1 posts, last login 2.9 days ago
mike....1 posts, last login 1.7 days ago
alexp...3 posts, last login 1.2 days ago
After not logging in for 2 days, Mike defends himself just 12 minutes after my post:
Hey Guys,
I'm definitely on board to join the lynchmob!
And Judy apparently doesn't like the idea of voting out one of the 3 least actives:
Okay. If we use the "who's on most" idea, then be prepared for an onslaught (like that "Pilgrims") of senseless drivel. Which I guess is not much different than what's going on now. I say everyone vote for the native (or pilgrim) on their left. 
I then mentioned that someone must have warned Mike:
The people who logged on after my post and before Mike's post were:
annie, chris, dan, judy, paula, sarah, son, and tulley.
Judy then claims that I am a witch:
Well, well. I see that Amer is the first to throw out a specific name (Mike) and with what I think is rather weak rationale. (Read all of the posts, Mike was on at 2:58.) It seems to me that Amer is a witch and attempting to direct those of us who are pure in heart to a non-witch Native.
Mike claims that Dan is the one who informed him:
Amer, you are very logical and make a good ally. Your logic is spurious, however. I was informed via telelphone call from someone I am related to to post because I was in danger.
Dan claims this is true:
I am, but the question remains whether I called him out of a game alliance, because we're brothers, or because I simply wanted some help understanding the game and that he was being posted about came up.
Judy again protects the non-participators and then implies that I must be a witch because I won immunity:
Due to our history of oft voting off the silent ones first, it would be a good witch strategy to talk away. How did a member of the Natives and the Pilgrims each have a player who garnered a perfect score? Could it be the witches shared information to send one of their own to the immunity box?
Mike surprisingly agrees with Judy:
Judy, you make good points. I really like the point of the vampire wanting to know what is going on in both camps. I will keep this in mind to see if the vampire goofs. If I am not mistaken, the witches know who each other are so that would possibly explain why someone from both teams was able to get each challenge correct.
It would seem that people are helping people, and those more likely to help would be witches?
After two days of inactivity and being nominated for elimination, Stinky Pete (a.k.a. AlexP) finally logs in and defends Mike, for some reason:
Yeah I had a midterm to study for. I already find Amer and son double reverse suspect by their focus on mike, and by Amer's use of a magical fire crotch as his avatar. Therefore, I will probably vote for the other alex (to avoid confusion) or annie, because it's the first week and I have nothing to go on. Argue away!
Judy then claims we should vote for Son or Annie:
Well, if we're going to use the, "if you're not posting then you can't possibly be a witch" so don't vote out the inactive, then can we assume that the most active are witches trying to stir up trouble? If so, then we should vote for Son (41) or Annie (27). I'm just about to change my vote to Son. I came on strong in defense of his not being a witch and he just threw me under the bus.
Now that we know that Mike was a witch, it casts heavy suspicion on those that were defending him: Judy, Dan, and Stinky Pete (a.k.a. AlexP). I find it highly likely the Judy and Stinky Pete are both witches as well. Once we get the voting data, we should have even more evidence.
First, I mentioned the three least active natives:
mike....1 posts, last login 1.7 days ago
alexp...3 posts, last login 1.2 days ago
After not logging in for 2 days, Mike defends himself just 12 minutes after my post:
I'm definitely on board to join the lynchmob!
And Judy apparently doesn't like the idea of voting out one of the 3 least actives:
I then mentioned that someone must have warned Mike:
annie, chris, dan, judy, paula, sarah, son, and tulley.
Judy then claims that I am a witch:
Mike claims that Dan is the one who informed him:
Dan claims this is true:
Judy again protects the non-participators and then implies that I must be a witch because I won immunity:
Mike surprisingly agrees with Judy:
It would seem that people are helping people, and those more likely to help would be witches?
After two days of inactivity and being nominated for elimination, Stinky Pete (a.k.a. AlexP) finally logs in and defends Mike, for some reason:
Judy then claims we should vote for Son or Annie:
Now that we know that Mike was a witch, it casts heavy suspicion on those that were defending him: Judy, Dan, and Stinky Pete (a.k.a. AlexP). I find it highly likely the Judy and Stinky Pete are both witches as well. Once we get the voting data, we should have even more evidence.
