Day 6 Discussion

[Mac Murdock]

May 13, 2020 15:14:01 GMT -8 Stabby said:

When it was 4/5 for Buzzfly, why didn't you vote earlier Mac?

Since I have immunity (and it will probably change before the next day) my list of remaining villians goes like this:
Erok
Mike
Buzzfly
Bsketchy

I was never really convinced that Buzzfly is a villain and I like some of their defense (although the posts that drew comparisons to trebec was concerning)

Erok on the other hand has 100% been helping the villains. He's either lying about his power or his ineptitude has cost lives.

[Stabby]

Remember those gasoline canisters that I wanted to use on EROK? Those were a waste.

My assumption was Erok was going to die by the law, since prior, he NEVER posted. Posting now of ALL times will push you up as a villian.

This means that with my current data of the time, the two top suspects I had was you and Buzzfly. I was more incline to kill Buzzfly and leave Erok to be death-by-mayor.

Obviously that isn't happening now because he is suddenly "active.

With that, it was between you, Buzzfly and Erok, and me choosing to believe Chris Mac at the time (read my posts and you'll see).

I pegged you as suspicious because StinkyPete got blocked, but you told me you blocked Farrell. That was inconsistent data point and makes me think you were trying to lie to me. I later crafted a theory that made sense FOR YOU that Annie could switched Farrell and StinkyPete, resulting in you seeing you block Farrel, but StinkyPete getting blocked.

The more I discuss with you in public forums, the more I could trust you.

I have already said that I blocked Buzzfly last night. He doesn't have the kiss of death.
StinkyPete visited you last night and you visited no one. You don't have the kiss of death.

Since Erok who was almost guaranteed killed-by-mayor is now going to survive another night. Mac has immunity, so he can't be killed.

Erok doesn't and he is the one person I can't verify his whereabouts at night with my complete data.

So as why I am saying with 99.9% (Because I believe a villain has the ability to forge night results), I think Erok is both the forger and has the kiss of death.

[Mike Lenin]

May 13, 2020 15:22:41 GMT -8 Mac Murdock said:

May 13, 2020 15:14:01 GMT -8 Stabby said:

When it was 4/5 for Buzzfly, why didn't you vote earlier Mac?

Since I have immunity (and it will probably change before the next day) my list of remaining villians goes like this:
Erok
Mike
Buzzfly
Bsketchy

I was never really convinced that Buzzfly is a villain and I like some of their defense (although the posts that drew comparisons to trebec was concerning)

Erok on the other hand has 100% been helping the villains. He's either lying about his power or his ineptitude has cost lives.

I have MAC as a vilain. I am not a villain and have proven as such.
This concocted theory is trying to frame EROK!

[Mac Murdock]

May 13, 2020 15:26:19 GMT -8 Mike Lenin said:

May 13, 2020 15:22:41 GMT -8 Mac Murdock said:

Since I have immunity (and it will probably change before the next day) my list of remaining villians goes like this:
Erok
Mike
Buzzfly
Bsketchy

I was never really convinced that Buzzfly is a villain and I like some of their defense (although the posts that drew comparisons to trebec was concerning)

Erok on the other hand has 100% been helping the villains. He's either lying about his power or his ineptitude has cost lives.

I have MAC as a vilain. I am not a villain and have proven as such.
This concocted theory is trying to frame EROK!

Correct me if i'm wrong:
Erok can save someone from the villains night kill
Erok has only attempted to use his powers once


again: villainous lies or blatant negligence...you can decide

[Mike Lenin]

May 13, 2020 15:23:33 GMT -8 Stabby said:

Remember those gasoline canisters that I wanted to use on EROK? Those were a waste.

My assumption was Erok was going to die by the law, since prior, he NEVER posted. Posting now of ALL times will push you up as a villian.

This means that with my current data of the time, the two top suspects I had was you and Buzzfly. I was more incline to kill Buzzfly and leave Erok to be death-by-mayor.

Obviously that isn't happening now because he is suddenly "active.

With that, it was between you, Buzzfly and Erok, and me choosing to believe Chris Mac at the time (read my posts and you'll see).

I pegged you as suspicious because StinkyPete got blocked, but you told me you blocked Farrell. That was inconsistent data point and makes me think you were trying to lie to me. I later crafted a theory that made sense FOR YOU that Annie could switched Farrell and StinkyPete, resulting in you seeing you block Farrel, but StinkyPete getting blocked.

The more I discuss with you in public forums, the more I could trust you.

I have already said that I blocked Buzzfly last night. He doesn't have the kiss of death.
StinkyPete visited you last night and you visited no one. You don't have the kiss of death.

Since Erok who was almost guaranteed killed-by-mayor is now going to survive another night. Mac has immunity, so he can't be killed.

Erok doesn't and he is the one person I can't verify his whereabouts at night with my complete data.

So as why I am saying with 99.9% (Because I believe a villain has the ability to forge night results), I think Erok is both the forger and has the kiss of death.

The Mayor had to prod EROK to join the game, and we had to prod him to even vote in the right thread. He rectified it, and then peaced out.
He is playing the game like a lost hero.

Think about how the Chris MAC and Farrell pounced when you and Merlot voted for EROK.
Please consider retracting your vote and lets discuss our ideas a bit further.

[Mike Lenin]

May 13, 2020 15:30:57 GMT -8 Mac Murdock said:

May 13, 2020 15:26:19 GMT -8 Mike Lenin said:

I have MAC as a vilain. I am not a villain and have proven as such.
This concocted theory is trying to frame EROK!

Correct me if i'm wrong:
Erok can save someone from the villains night kill
Erok has only attempted to use his powers once


again: villainous lies or blatant negligence...you can decide

BLATANT NEGLIGENCE!!!

[Mac Murdock]

well, fuck mike, what do you want me to do?
and before you say it, no, I won't vote for myself

[Mike Lenin]

Well played Mac. Again.
I just hope we have a chance to die another day.

[Mike Lenin]

May 13, 2020 14:48:19 GMT -8 merlotbrougham said:

Erok

1. Deliberately ignored other questions in a post he directly responded to.

2. Hasn't said anything until the mod made him.

3. Process of Elimination

Reads:
Hero: Stabby Bsketchy, Farrell, Codemonkey, Mike.

Remaining: Buzzfly, Mac, Erok

Compared to Erok, Buzzfly has been at least addressing my quesiton, and although Stabby makes a good point, Buzzfly appears like he is at least trying to be open about it. I also agree with what Stabby has deduced regarding kiss of death. Also some of buzzfly's recent activity does look a little like hero frustration to me.

Mac could be a villain, but has less villain equity than erok because he interacted with Annie when he didn't need to, he continuously brought up the lie detector attempts in order to get people to go along with it, and took the time and effort to put together and post publicly all the information that he had about night actions and results. What's the motivation for a villain to do these things? It goes against everything they are trying to do.

This is not to say that Mac & Buzzfly are out of the pool of suspects, however, this is why I feel Erok is a better option for today.

Death to villains! I am casting my vote for Erok in the voting thread now.

I was trying to warn against this. This was a red herring post. It happened early when it meant not as much. A set up for later in the game.

[Evan]

May 13, 2020 9:59:04 GMT -8 Jesse "Codemonkey" Young said:

May 13, 2020 7:13:15 GMT -8 Stabby said:

Evan: 3

Has the mayor ever been killed in a Mildville before?

I think the mob is going for Buzzfly - my vote is going in.


(Post 5 of ?)

I didn't remember this, but did some digging and the answer is YES!

Here, I cleaned this up as much as I could, though the main article still continues on the side column.Gazette Season 5 Week 1.pdf (237.01 KB)